(Continued from December article) 

Part 4 – Classical repertoire and presentations in the later years 

Background 

The 1960s and 70s saw the pinnacle of LP production of classical music worldwide, now recorded in stereo.  The major UK labels were EMI (Columbia, Parlophone and HMV), European labels DG, Erato, Melodya and Supraphon, and in US, RCA, Mercury and CBS.  Major recording artists, both well-established and emerging, were contracted to one or other of these labels, many exclusively.  At this period recording companies had not agglomerated and consequently each label issued competitive basic repertoire, sometimes duplicating or triplicating within their own label as well as recording and releasing lesser known repertoire as never before. (Multiple Beethoven symphony cycles within a label abounded.) 

From a formidable choice, examples of major releases in these times include the Decca/Solti and DG Karajan Wagner Ring cycles, the complete Haydn symphonies played by Dorati and the Philomusica Hungarica on Decca, Philips recording of Berlioz’s Les Troyens, Decca recordings of almost all of Britten’s works, conducted by Britten and likewise most Stravinsky works conducted by Stravinsky.  Other notable opera releases included the Decca Mackerras Janacek operas and DG Strauss operas under Bohm.  This was the era of the proliferation of boxed sets of complete oeuvres such as complete Beethoven piano sonatas under Kempff, (DG), Arrau, (Philips) and Barenboim (EMI), complete Beethoven quartets with Quartetto Italiano (Philips), complete Mozart Marches and Dances Boskovsky/Vienna Mozart Ensemble (Decca), Fischer-Dieskau singing almost the entire leider baritone repertoire and much, much more. 

Recording artists 

Elder statesmen conductors such as Ansermet and Monteux (Decca), Klemperer (EMI), Bohm (DG and EMI), Karajan (DG and EMI), Munch (RCA), Paray (Mercury), Szell (CBS), Stokowski (multi labels) and younger and emerging conductors continued to record prolifically.  The newer generation included Solti (Decca), Bernstein (CBS and DG), Dorati (Mercury and Decca), Giulini (DG and EMI), Kempe (EMI), Carlos Kleiber (GG and EMI), Jochum EMI and DG), Haitink (Philips), Abbado (Decca), Mehta (Decca), Davis (EMI and Philips), Marriner (multi labels) and Mackerras (multi labels) 

Major pianists included Arrau (EMI Philips), Curzon (Decca), Horowitz (CBS), Kempff (Decca DG), Gilels (EMI DG), Richter (multi labels), Rubinstein (RCA), Serkin (CBS) and younger emerging pianists such as Michelangeli (Decca), Katchen (Decca), Pollini (EMI DG) and Argerich (EMI DG). 

Prominent violinists were Oistrakh (EMI and DG), Kogan (EMI), Heifetz (RCA), Stern (CBS), Milstein (EMI and DG), Grumiaux (Philips), Suk (EMI Supraphon) and emerging Perlman (EMI) and Zukerman (CBS).  Rostropovich was the outstanding cellist (EMI and DG), other notable cellists being Starker (EMI), Fournier (EMI and DG) and of course, the ill-fated Jaqueline du Pre (EMI).  

String Trios and Quartets included the Beaux Art Trio (Philips), Amadeus quartet (DG), Quartetto Italiano (Philips) and Budapest quartet (CBS). 

Major singers abounded most in opera and song, De los Angeles (EMI). Schwarzkopf (EMI), Ludwig (EMI and DG). Fischer-Dieskau (EMI and DG), Wunderlich (EMI and DG).  Joan Sutherland (Decca), Franco Corelli (EMI) and Tito Gobbi were in their prime and Luciano Pavarotti and Placido Domingo were emerging as the major tenors of this and future eras.  

The roles of record producers and engineers were beyond importance.  Producers for the major labels were commanding figures such as Walter Legge at Columbia/EMI, John Culshaw at Decca, John McClure at CBS, Richard Mohr at RCA and Robert Fine and Wilma Cozart at Mercury were the most prominent.    

Repertoire expanded significantly for the music of Bach and his contemporaries with specialist labels such as Archive, a subsidiary of DG, Argo, Harmonia Mundi and Teldec, as well as much output from mainstream Decca and German based EMI Electrola. 

The major conductors in this repertoire were Karl Richter (Archive), Karl Munchinger (Decca), Nicolaus Harnoncourt, and Gustav Leonhardt.  The latter two commenced recording the complete Bach cantatas in 1971 on Teldec. 

Historical recordings from the 78 era were edited and re-released.  Of particular note were Toscanini’s New York, Philadelphia and NBC orchestral recordings and Rachmaninoff’s conducting and playing his own works and playing the piano music of many other composers. 

World Record Club 

During the 60s the WRC expanded its label sources, now issuing alongside numerous EMI and Erato LPs, Decca (very significantly), Philips, DG, Unicorn and Harmonia Mundi.  The addition of these labels and other labels allowed a considerable expansion of repertoire and also, often, major releases.  Particular examples of these are the release of the 1963 Bohm Mozart Cosi fan Tutte (EMI) and the famous Beethoven 5th symphony under Carlos Kleiber from DG. 

Some repertoire was replicated with different performers eg the Pathetique symphony was variously issued under conductors Mathieson, Giulini, Furtwangler and Rostropovich. Klemperer’s esteemed Beethoven symphony cycle, originally released in Australia on Columbia was reissued through WRC as individual LPs and subsequently as a boxed set.  (His famous Fidelio was also re-issued through WRC.) 

The club continued to issue “historical” performances, changing its titling from Connoisseur to perhaps the more accurate Retrospect.  The specialist label of Record Society disappeared in the mid sixties.  Its “specialist” repertoire was now included under the general WRC label. 

In comparison with light music, release of Australian works and/or performers was rare.  However, one release was an LP comprising Nigel Butterley’s In the Head the Fire, Alfred Hill’s Linthorpe and Robert Hughes’s Sinfonietta.  These were performed by John Hopkins with the Sydney Symphony Orchestra, Sir Bernard Heinze with the Sydney Symphony orchestra and Willem van Otterloo with the Melbourne Symphony orchestra respectively.  This recording was produced by the Australian Broadcasting Commission.   

Two other releases, produced by RCA in collaboration with ABC and surely unique were of piano roll recordings of Percy Grainger playing the Greig concerto and Tchaikovsky 1st concerto on two separate LPs, both accompanied by a freshly recorded by John Hopkins and the Sydney and Melbourne Symphony Orchestras respectively.  The fillers were a 1950 recording by Leopold Stokowski and the Stokowski orchestra playing Grainger miscellany and piano roll Grainger playing his arrangement of the waltz from the Nutcracker ballet. 

Examples of WRC releases 

A table of some of the issues follows.  This is a sample only of a much larger number of issues but demonstrates the breadth of the repertoire, quality of performers and expanded sourced overseas labels. 

Original recording label Composer Work Artists WRC label 
ABC (Australia) Butterley/ Hill/Hughes In the Head of Fire/Linthorpe/Sinfonietta Hopkins/SSO/Heinze/SSO/Van Otterloo/MSO WRC 
Academy Sound and Vision CPE Bach/ Hoffmeister Flute concerti Dingfelder/Mackerras/English Chamber WRC 
Argo Handel Messiah Marriner/ASMF Boxed set 
Decca Beethoven Septet  Vienna Octet WRC 
 Brahms Complete piano works Katchen Boxed set 
 Britten War Requiem Soloists/Britten LSO Boxed set 
 Elgar Dream of Gerontius Soloists/Britten LSO Boxed set 
 Gounod Faust Sutherland/Corelli/ Ghiaurov/Bonynge/LSO Boxed set 
 Hadyn 7 Last Words of Christ Marriner WRC 
 Mozart Complete Wind Music London Wind Soloists Boxed set 
 Mozart La Clemenza di Tito Soloists/Kertesz/Vienna State Opera Boxed set 
 Mozart Complete Dances and Marches Boskovsky/Vienna Mozart Ensemble WRC individual LPs 
 Schoenberg/ Scriabin Transfigured Night/Poem of Ecstasy Mehta/Los Angeles Philharmonic WRC 
 Schumann Symphonies 1 and 4 Krips/London Symphony WRC 
 Strauss Salome Soloists/Solti/Vienna Philharmonic Boxed set 
 Strauss Elecktra Soloists/Solti/Vienna philharmonic Boxed set 
DG Beethoven Symphonies 5 C. Kleiber/Vienna Philharmonic WRC 
 Sibelius Lemminkäinen/Karelia suites Kamu/Helsinki Radio Symphony WRC 
Original recording label Composer Work Artists WRC label 
EMI-Columbia/HMV CPE Bach Flute concertos Dingfelder/Mackerras/ English Chamber WRC 
 Beethoven Symphonies  1-9 Klemperer/Philharmonia LPs and Boxed set 
  Fidelio Soloists/Klemperer/ Philharmonia Boxed set 
  Missa Solemnis Soloists/Klemperer/New Philharmonia LPs  
  String quartets Busch quartet Boxed set 
 Brahms Violin concertos Oistrakh/Szell/Cleveland WRC 
 Chopin Scherzi 1-4 Richter WRC 
 Donizetti Lucia di Lammermoor Callas/Soloists/Serafin/Philharmonia Boxed set 
 Hadyn Paris Symphonies Ansermet/Suisse Romande Boxed set 
 Hadyn 7 Last Words of Christ Marriner/ASMF WRC 
 Honegger Symphonies 1 to 5 Plasson/Toulouse Orchestra Boxed set 
 Mendelssohn/Bruch Violin concertos Milstein/Barzin/ Philharmonia WRC 
 Mozart Cosi fan Tutte Soloists/Bohm/Philharmonia Boxed set 
 Offenbach Orpheus in the Underworld Soloists/Plasson/Toulouse Orchestra Boxed set 
 Rossini Barber of Seville Soloists/Galleria/Philharmonia Boxed set 
 Smetana The Bartered Bride Soloists/Kempe/Bamberg Symphony Boxed set 
 Schubert Piano works Schnabel Boxed set 
  Wander Fantasy/Sonata D664 Richter WRC 
 Sibelius Various Berglund/Bournemouth Symphony WRC 
 Tchaikowsky Symphonies  Rostropovich/London Philharmonic WRC 
 Tchaikowsky Piano concertos 1 to 3 Gilels/Maazel/New Philharmonia WRC 
 Verdi Il Trovatore Schippers/Rome Opera Boxed set 
 Wagner Lohengrin Kempe/Soloists/Vienna State Boxed set 
 Walton Symphony 1 Haitink/Philharmonia WRC 
 Various Spanish  De Burgos/Paris Conservetoire WRC 
 Various Violin pieces Perlman/Martinon/Orchestra of Paris WRC 
Original recording label Composer Work Artists WRC label 
EMI -Columbia/HMV Various 100th Anniversary BPO Various/Berlin Philharmonic Boxed set 
 Various Various Dennis Brain/various Boxed set 
Erato Handel Fireworks Music Jean-François Paillard/JFP Orchestra WRC 
 Handel Dixit Dominus Gardiner/Monteverdi Choir and Orchestra WRC 
Harmonia Mundi Beethoven Septet  Collegium Areum WRC 
 Greig Complete Peer Gynt Dreier/London Symphony WRC 
L’Oiseau-Lyre  Clementi Piano Sonatas Crowson Record Society 
Melodiya/HMV Schubert Piano Sonatas and short works Richter WRC 
 Shostakovich Symphony no 7 Svetlanov/USSR Symphony WRC 
 JS Bach Goldberg variations Leonhardt WRC 
Philips Liszt Piano concertos 1&2 Richter/Kondrashin/ London Symphony WRC 
  Ravel Various Haitink/Concertgebouw WRC 
   Various lieder & songs Souzay/Baldwin WRC 
RCA/ABC Greig/Grainger Piano concerto 1/Grainger various Grainger/Hopkins/Sydney Symphony/Stokowski/Stokowski Orchestra WRC 
 Tchaikowsky/Grainger Piano concerto 1/Flower waltz Grainger/Hopkins/Melbourne Symphony WRC 
Unicorn Mahler Symphony no 1 Horenstein/London Symphony WRC 
 Beethoven Piano concerto 1784 and fragments Blumental WRC 
World Record Club (UK) Elgar/Parry The Music Makers/Blest Pair of Sirens Baker/Boult/London Philharmonic WRC 

The next article of this series describes the presentations and some technical aspects of the WRC LPs in these later years of the Club. 
 
David Edmonds 

References:

DE’s personal LP collection 


Please click HERE to read part 1, 2, 3 and 5